All criminal case solicitors in Offaly / Laois still withholding Legal Aid services


‘some defendants are in fact vulnerable people who lead chaotic lives and the sooner the dispute is resolved the better’
THERE is a continuing withdrawal of Legal Aid services for criminal cases by all solicitors in Offaly and Laois (District Number 15), with no end in sight to the dispute.
All the solicitors handling criminal cases in the District Courts of District 15 withdrew their services on Wednesday, June 17, causing widespread adjournments at Tullamore District Court and Tullamore Circuit Court in the dispute over the flat-rate fee changes proposed by the Minister for Justice Jim O'Callaghan. The Minister subsequently suggested changes to his proposal but the Offaly and Laois solicitors say this doesn't go far enough and they will therefore continue to withhold their services.
In Tullamore District Court the busiest solicitors are Brian Duffy, Patrick Martin and Aisling Maloney, and the busiest barristers are Paul Nocter and David Nugent but for the last two months their criminal case work has, for all intents and purposes, come to an effective standstill.
Brian Duffy told the Tribune that the Minister's engagement with the solicitors has been “very disappointing”. He pointed out that under the new flat-rate system if a client decides to change solicitor midway through his / her case then it will mean that the original solicitor will be left without a payment. “Also, if a matter does go to multiple appearances there will be no possibility of applying for a new cert, which again will be to our disadvantage.”
Solicitors throughout the country have also been highlighting the fact that under the new scheme it would mean they would only get paid at the end of a case which would cause significant cash flow issues to legal firms.
Minister O'Callaghan says he wants the flat fee payment system because he wants to mitigate against the amount of adjournments sought by solicitors for legal aid cases. Mr Duffy said this was a “false narrative” and a “laughable notion. The truth is that Judge Andrew Cody runs Tullamore District Court in an efficient way and we solicitors also act efficiently. In truth it's very rare that solicitors would misuse the system by seeking as many adjournments as possible. That is simply not the way places like Tullamore District Court operate."
Under the flat fee scheme Solicitors will receive one fixed fee of €520 for representing a legally aided person before the District Court. Previously solicitors were paid €239.38 for a first appearance and €59.86 for each subsequent appearance.
Solicitors point out that criminal defence work is not lucrative and involves long hours. “Sometimes I have to go through a lengthy amount of disclosure (evidence),” remarked Mr Duffy. “For example I recently, in one case, had to work through 84 pages of disclosure.” The work they do is very necessary and important. Legal Aid has been described as being “the safety net that guarantees equality before the law to the most vulnerable and disadvantaged, ensuring that fairness is not limited to those who can afford it.”
Mr Duffy commented that some defendants are in fact “vulnerable people who lead chaotic lives” and the sooner the dispute is resolved the better.
He said all the solicitors are concerned about the growing backlog of cases. All of them are keen to get back to work, “but we are all very disappointed by the Minister's lack of proper engagement with us. Some people say the Minister is engaged in a cost cutting exercise but in fact the Legal Aid system represents only 1% of the Department of Justice's budget. All the solicitors in District 15 regret the impact on the Court, Court staff and the Gardaí, who are all impacted by the withdrawal of services, but also our clients who have to try and navigate the system on their own. All we are seeking is for a fair system based on a realistic assessment of the criminal justice system, not just regurgitated headlines without any independent evidence or assessment."
