Tullamore District Court remains at a standstill due to solicitors' strike


Solicitors are dissatisfied with how they have been treated by the Department of Justice
TULLAMORE District Court remained at a standstill on Wednesday, July 1, as the solicitors once again stated that they had withdrawn their services in tandem with the nationwide solicitors' strike over the proposed change to the Legal Aid payment scheme.
There were 51 cases brought before Judge Eamon Carroll from the usual starting time of 10.30am onwards and every single case was put off to a later day. Most of the cases were adjourned to either Wednesday July 22 or Wednesday September 9.
Solicitors Aisling Maloney, Patrick Martin and Brian Duffy all told Judge Carroll at the outset of the court sitting that they were withdrawing their services as part of the nationwide strike. “I am also withdrawing my services today,” commented Mr Martin, “and I apologise for that.” The three solicitors walked out of the court just a few minutes into the sitting.
The Judge explained to a number of the defendants why their cases couldn't be heard today. “Solicitors aren't generally available today,” he told one defendant. “So, hopefully they will be available on the next day, which will be July 22.”
In one case where there was no appearance by either the defendant or her solicitor Judge Carroll said he wouldn't issue a bench warrant for the defendant's arrest “because I am not certain what advice the solicitor might have given his client.”
To another defendant he remarked, “Unfortunately, the Legal Aid scheme isn't operating at the moment.”
Adjourning another case to September 9 he commented, “Hopefully your solicitor will be available to represent you on that date.”
“Do you have a solicitor?” the Judge asked a defendant. “Yeah,” said the defendant, “but he's on strike at the moment.”
Barrister David Nugent remained on in court after the solicitors' departure but he didn't act on behalf of any defendants apart from assisting in a couple of technical matters.
This is the third week in a row that Tullamore District Court has failed to function because of the dispute with the Minister for Justice.
On Wednesday June 17 numerous cases in Tullamore Court went unheard due to what Judge Andrew Cody called “a strike” by the legal representatives, Ms Maloney, Mr Martin and Mr Duffy. These three solicitors handle the vast majority of the local cases where legal aid is granted.
On June 17 the three legal representatives said they were taking the action individually but their withdrawal was part of a wider move by lawyers nationally following talks involving the Law Society.
The Department of Justice is introducing a flat-fee system of payment for work involving accused people who are granted legal aid. Legal aid is granted by a sitting judge once the court is satisfied the applicant cannot afford to employ a solicitor themselves.
Speaking to the Tribune outside the courtroom, Mr Martin said solicitors were dissatisfied with how they had been treated by the Department of Justice when the changes were proposed. He was disappointed with the engagement by the department with the Law Society and with the emergency legislation which was being used to introduce the changes. Mr Martin and his colleagues all spoke of how the workload on solicitors had increased in recent years. In addition, more people were being granted legal aid in circumstances of inflation and cost of living increases.
On Friday morning, June 26, Solicitors in Nenagh withdrew their services in Nenagh District Court due to changes that were going to be made to Legal Aid on July 1st. The Nenagh solicitors said these changes would be “unfair, unworkable, and would undermine access to Justice." Said Solicitor Ian MacNamara: “Our concern is that this does not represent the amount of work that goes into each case. The one size fits all is not workable. Regarding the most vulnerable members of society, such as those in custody or juveniles, that require a sizeable amount of attendances in court, the one payment puts a limit on the amount of legal aid services that we can provide to any person.”
Minister for Justice Jim O'Callaghan is introducing a €520 flat fee for criminal legal aid paid to solicitors. Currently, a solicitor is paid for each court appearance, starting at €239.38, and then €59.86 for each subsequent hearing. However, Minister O'Callaghan has said this will now be replaced with a once-off flat fee of €520 per defendant, regardless of the number of court appearances. He said there have been "abuses going on in the system", and there have been numerous examples of persons being charged with more than one offence, which leads to payments of €240 per offence. He believes the once-off fee of €520 would make the system more efficient.
President of the Law Society Rosemarie Loftus pointed out that solicitors across the country have resigned from the criminal legal aid scheme as a result. She said this will have a "devastating impact" on access to justice. She said the Minister for Justice wrote to the Law Society and said he was pressing ahead with the flat fee, regardless of the serious concerns the legal profession has raised. "The people who will pay the price are victims of crime, who will see trials delayed, as well as some of the most vulnerable in society. They are children in trouble for the first time. They are people struggling with addiction or serious mental health conditions. They are people who are homeless, victims of trafficking, and people in acute crisis.”
