Court hears man burned his sister's caravan in Tullamore housing estate


A MAN who burned his sister's caravan has been jailed and must pay her €5,000 within 18 months of his release from prison.
John McDonagh (35), Church Hill, Tullamore, was sentenced to three-and-a-half years in prison, including one year suspended, for arson at Church Hill on May 15, 2021.
Mr McDonagh's plea of guilty to that offence was made at Tullamore Circuit Court where charges of criminally damaging the caravan and threatening to damage it were taken into consideration.
Judge Keenan Johnson heard how the accused recorded the crime and posted it on social media on a day when he was very intoxicated.
Garda Brendan McSweeney said that after observing the burned out remains of the caravan on the afternoon of May 15 last year he called to 57 Church Hill and spoke to the accused's father, John McDonagh Senior who said the caravan was his daughter Amanda's and she lived in it with her partner.
Gardai learned that before the fire John McDonagh had contacted his sister by phone to say he was going to burn the caravan.
Amanda McDonagh was visiting family in the south of the country at the time but she later saw her brother on a Facebook live video admitting the crime.
She told a garda that all her belongings were in “the trailer”, including baby scans.
The day before the fire she had told Offaly County Council she wanted to move her caravan and leave Tullamore.
She had also learned by phone before the fire that the trailer had been smashed up and when she spoke to her brother John he was roaring and intoxicated and threatened to burn the caravan but she did not believe him.
Nothing was left of the caravan afterwards but a steel frame and Ms McDonagh said her partner had bought it for €11,000 from a cousin.
Garda McSweeney said he arrested John McDonagh after he approached the patrol car in Church Hill when he was “highly intoxicated” and he said things about his sister's partner.
In an interview with gardai he said he believed Amanda's partner had it in for him and he feared his own caravan would be burned.
He started the fire by taking a blanket from the caravan, lighting it, and then throwing it back in. He had used a slashhook to break the windows.
Mr McDonagh had 24 previous convictions, including 11 for road traffic offences, six for public order offences, four for causing criminal damage, one for endangerment and another for production of a weapon.
The endangerment offence, which arose from an incident where a number of people were driving dangerously in Tullamore, was committed on August 27, 2019 and on conviction for it on March 12, 2021, he was sentenced to three-and-a-half years in jail, but the sentence was suspended for 10 years.
The court heard the accused now resides in Edenderry, had not come to garda notice since May, 2021, and had eight children, six from one relationship and two from another.
Defence counsel told Judge Johnson that Mr McDonagh had committed an incredibly stupid offence and there was a history between himself and his brother-in-law.
He had started the fire in a state of extreme intoxication and had since stopped drinking and taking drugs.
He had apologised to his sister and was conscious of the need to offer compensation.
Judge Johnson said arson could not be tolerated and noted the caravan was set on fire in a residential estate.
In addition to paying compensation of €5,000, he must also remain under the supervision of the probation service for 18 months after his release.
The judge also noted that this offence triggered the activation of the earlier sentence for endangerment and said he would deal with that on December 20 next.