Man with address just outside Edenderry loses appeal for assaulting ex-wife

placeholder image

A man whose conviction for assaulting his ex-wife was based solely on her familiarity with his voice, according to his lawyers, has lost an appeal against his conviction. 

Laurence Carthy (43), with an address at Ballyhagan, Carbury, Co Kildare, pleaded not guilty to assault causing harm to his ex-wife Joanne Carthy on May 5, 2016. 

Naas Circuit Criminal Court heard that Carthy's ex-wife woke to find a man's hand over her face, preventing her from breathing. She was pushed from the bed to the floor where she managed to escape. 

She gave evidence in the trial that she was able to identify the intruder as Carthy by his voice when he uttered the phrase: "it's just because I miss you so much".

She went on to say, "I knew it was him. I knew the way he was breathing, whatever grunt or whatever.”

It was established that there was no forced entry, Carthy had retained a key, and there was no evidence that the family dog barked on an intruder entering the house. 

Carthy was found guilty by a jury and sentenced to three years imprisonment with the final 18 months suspended by Judge Brian O’Callaghan on July 2, 2018. 

He lost an appeal against his conviction on Friday, March 29, with the Court of Appeal holding that the voice recognition evidence was of sufficient quality to convict. 

Ms Justice Isobel Kennedy said the witness was very familiar with the voice she identified, as she had been in a relationship with Carthy for 17 years. 

She said the manner in which Carthy was breathing or grunting was something a spouse or partner would be familiar with. Crucially, her assailant responded to her when she asked: “is that you, Lar, really?”

Counsel for Carthy, Kate Egan BL, submitted that the only evidence against her client was that of the injured party and, in the absence of supportive features, the evidence was so frail that it gave rise to a potential miscarriage of justice. 

Ms Egan said voice recognition was weaker than visual identification or other recognition evidence and the injured party had limited opportunity to reach her conclusion in the course of, what must have been, an extremely fraught situation. 

Ms Justice Kennedy said it was “difficult to conceive of a situation of greater familiarity than such as pertained in this case, which included not only familiarity with the voice in issue but also with other features.”

Furthermore, Ms Justice Kennedy said the injured party was extensively and skillfully cross-examined by Carthy’s barrister, Ms Egan.  

She said the holding of a formal voice identification procedure would have served little purpose, given the circumstances of the assault and the victim’s familiarity with the voice in question. In any event, it would have been impossible to recreate the circumstances of the identification, the judge held. 

Further grounds of appeal related to the trial judge’s rulings and refusal to discharge the jury, following the introduction of alleged prejudicial evidence, were also dismissed. 

Powered by
Register
Follow us
© 2026 Formpress Publishing LTD. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice