'Deeply frustrating': Concerns raised as cost of Midlands Hospice soars to €40 million


Offaly TDs John Clendennen and Tony McCormack have highlighted that the long-awaited hospice needs to be delivered as soon as possible.
Offaly TDs John Clendennen and Tony McCormack have expressed their frustration with the continued uncertainty surrounding the delivery of the Midlands Hospice in Tullamore.
Representatives from the Department of Health and the Health Service Executive (HSE) were before the Joint Oireachtas Committee on Infrastructure and National Development Plan Delivery on Wednesday, September 30 and faced questions in relation to the delayed delivery of the Midlands Hospice.
Officials confirmed at the committee that a value engineering exercise is underway meaning that they could not provide a timeline for delivery.
During the exchange, the current cost of the project was confirmed as approximately €40 million and that a value engineering exercise is being undertaken following significant cost escalation, with representatives citing a 30% funding shortfall.
In September 2022, Government funding of €20 million was allocated for the hospice and a series of fundraising efforts were carried out locally afterwards to contribute towards the building of the project.
Speaking at the committee on Wednesday, Deputy Clendennen said: “The people of the Midlands have waited long enough for this hospice. Communities have fundraised, land has been secured and considerable work has already gone into overcoming the obstacles that have faced this project.”
The Fine Gael TD outlined his frustration at the continuous delays with the project. He commented: “What we need now is a clear delivery plan and a date for construction to begin. Instead, we learned today that a value engineering exercise is underway because of escalating costs, leading to a €12 million shortfall, while the HSE were unable to tell me when we will see a shovel in the ground.”
“This is deeply frustrating. The current project cost was confirmed to be €40 million and it is essential that any funding issues are addressed quickly and transparently rather than becoming another reason for delay. “
Deputy Clendennen also questioned whether changes arising from the value engineering process could result in a requirement to revisit planning permission. HSE representatives indicated that they considered this unlikely and hoped to work within the existing permission.
The Offaly TD remarked: “Value engineering cannot become another phrase for allowing an essential Midlands healthcare project to drift. I fully recognise that major capital projects have to demonstrate value for money but there also has to be accountability for delivery.”
Planning permission for the long-awaited facility was granted by An Coimisiún Pleanala back in June for a site at Arden Lane following a prolonged saga.
The planning permission outcome followed a series of appeals and objections which delayed the construction of the much-needed palliative care unit.
However, a start date for construction on the project has still not been set in the months since planning was approved and Deputy Clendennen says that the HSE must commit to the delivery of Midlands Hospice in Tullamore as soon as possible.
He noted: “This hospice is not an optional extra for the Midlands. There has been an enormous community effort behind it and people deserve certainty about when construction will commence. It was only earlier this month that the Midlands Palliative Care Alliance was officially launched, reinforcing the collaborative efforts made across the four Midlands counties towards this project.”
“The current value engineering exercise is concerning but as the last region in the country to have a dedicated palliative care facility this must be delivered ASAP.”
Fianna Fail TD for Offaly, Tony McCormack also questioned the Department of Health directly about the delays in progressing the new hospice in Tullamore at the Oireachtas Committee on Infrastructure and National Development Plan Delivery.
He explained: “We need to get the Midlands Hospice built. This is a hugely important project for Tullamore, Offaly and the wider Midlands, and we have waited long enough to see it delivered. The cheapest time to build it was yesterday. The next cheapest time is today.”
Deputy McCormack finished by saying: “Every further delay has a cost. Construction costs do not stand still, and more importantly, patients and families across the Midlands deserve access to a dedicated hospice facility as soon as possible. The planning permission is there. The need is there. Now we need to get it built.”
Officials are to come back to the Offaly TDs and the Committee with a timeframe for the delivery of the project.
